Is every tree planted by TreeSisters permanent?
By Lauriane Cayet-Boisrobert - 24 April, 2020
This is the first installment of a blog series that aims to explore in greater detail the answer given in the FAQ section of our website here.
What are the realities of reforestation?
You might wonder: How does TreeSisters ensure that the trees funded permanently re-robe our planet in green? Perhaps you imagine that every single tree is taken care of and protected by barbed-wire fences and guards from the communities involved in the projects we fund.
In this blog I will explain how our reforestation partners are ensuring the trees and forests you fund grow well, and also how they are monitored. Then I will explain the importance of respecting the communities’ needs. And finally, we will look at what happens to a tree regrown inside a forest versus an agroforestry tree.
Care and Maintenance
Our reforestation partners ensure the good maintenance of the funded trees (1) from two to up to 10 years after planting, depending on the project. In their experience, this is the period necessary to ensure the trees will continue to grow well on their own.
This maintenance is mostly about controlling weeds and creating firebreaks. A technique called "singling" is used by Eden Reforestation Projects in Madagascar and Nepal. It consists of converting a dense group of bushes or trees into taller trees, by only letting one stem grow into a trunk - the purpose being to swiftly create a canopy and shade for other species to thrive under.
Maintenance also requires the provision of advice and assistance to the communities and individuals involved. Our reforestation partner in India, Project GreenHands, visits the tree seedlings or saplings that were delivered to the farmers for two years, to troubleshoot and provide technical advice. This is necessary to ensure that the trees become self-sustainable, and that farmers are fully proficient at cultivating trees on their farms.
All trees assisted to naturally regenerate in the Atlantic forest restoration project in Brazil, receive maintenance and monitoring for 5 years after the site opens for regeneration. This includes isolating and protecting the area with fences and firebreaks, planting the fewest trees necessary to shade out weeds, and controlling invasive African grass around the trees for the first two years.
Our reforestation partners don’t monitor each individual tree forever. Instead, they monitor the overall process of regreening (2) and forest growth during a given period within permanent monitoring plots selected in reforestation sites
Our reforestation partners also monitor the annual survival rate of the tree seedlings for two to three years at randomly chosen sample plots. They undertake tree replacement, if needed, to retain the full amount of funded trees. The cost of tree replacement is always accounted for in the price per tree. (3)
Operating in new locations in Mozambique and in West Papua, Eden Reforestation Projects also monitors the annual survival rates of the tree seedlings at permanent monitoring plots within the planting sites for 10 years. These permanent plots are for long term monitoring of detailed changes in forest dynamics. Eden may also decide to enhance and adapt their reforestation practice depending on monitoring results.
Supporting local communities and sustainable ecosystems
A key element to always keep in mind, is that our reforestation projects occur in rural areas of developing countries. Communities that live in these areas are heavily dependent on surrounding trees and forests for their livelihoods.
In the tropics, people depend on trees to survive. Primary uses for timber products include fuelwood for cooking, building houses, making charcoal, fencing and poles. Local use of the forests by these communities have a significant impact: 30-40% of deforestation is due to local/subsistence agriculture. (4)
In order to protect and respect local communities that rely on timber and wood where we plant, it is impossible to impose strict and permanent protection of all the trees we fund. Imposing such protections would simply displace timber harvesting activities onto nearby forests; forests that could be carbon-rich, old growth and biodiverse. Local communities would continue to encroach on other nearby habitats by practicing slash-and-burn or swidden agriculture.
In order to protect high value forests from these potential impacts, it is important to respect people’s rights to access the forest.
Taking this into account, 20-30% of the trees that we fund (5) are for livelihood purposes, for the communities’ own consumption, and also for revenue generation from the sale of forest products, such as charcoal, honey, wild fruits and firewood, timber and many other non-timber forest products. By providing livelihood trees, we are also protecting nearby remnant and old growth forests.
Trees Growing Inside Forests
Many funded trees are eventually phased out over time, as they are fast-growing, native, pioneer (6) species planted to cover the ground. Some of the trees are planted just to attract seed-dispersing animals. They will be naturally or intentionally succeeded by more mature tree communities after 10-50 years. (7)
The regrowing forest will change and follow the natural dynamics of forest succession with time. The funded trees will be replaced by new species of trees and the planted forest will begin to resemble a maturing forest. Big trees will start dominating the canopy, and tree density may even drop.
A portion of the funded trees regrown inside forests are often reserved for livelihood purposes (see section above). About 10-20% of the trees we fund in the project in Nepal are reserved for livelihood purposes and some of them will be harvested to provide timber at maturity, as well as fuelwood and charcoal. However, there will be no full and permanent clearing of forests, and trees will be replaced according to a simple forest management plan. Certain species of trees can be assisted to regrow, or regrow naturally, after the removal of limbs, by resprouting from cut stumps or from seeds present in the soil waiting for favorable conditions.
Agroforestry trees, which are defined as trees planted for regreening farmlands, for ecosystem restoration and livelihood development, are well managed to live a long time. Some of them are not intended to be cut down.
Why? They provide crucial ecological or cultural services to farmers, such as increasing soil fertility, shade, soil moisture content, or to provide cultural functions. Trees grown for fodder or fuelwood are not necessarily cut down, as in the case of Grevillea Robusta in Kenya (read more here). Trees planted for fruit or nuts are never cut down as they provide food. They may provide an income, as for the Ashaninka people in the project we fund in Brazil. In addition to benefiting individuals, revenues from tree products can be reinvested for the good of the community (the local welfare system).
What about trees that need to be cut down? The farmers engaged in Project GreenHands, who have chosen to plant a combination of different native trees with the intention of harvesting them for timber at maturity will do so in a cycle. For example, they will cut down Teak trees in 15 to 20 years and Mahogany trees in 10 to 12 years. Under this system, there will always be trees and there will never be complete deforestation on the farm lot. Additionally, once farmers see the economic benefit derived from the trees, and understand it is in their best interest to plant trees, they have a strong incentive to re-plant.
As you can see, re-robing the Earth with trees isn't as black and white as ensuring the survival of every single tree. The healthiest future for our forests also requires sustainable livelihoods for human communities. Community-based approaches that support humans living in harmony with Nature enable us to aid the restoration of whole forests in the long-term.
In the second part of this blog series, we’ll look at how TreeSisters ensures the permanence of funded trees through clear land tenure and clearly defined land use rights - a critical pathway for sustainable reforestation and for halting deforestation and forest degradation in the tropics.
TreeSisters’ mission is to re-robe our planet in green by channeling donations into reforestation projects (8) in the tropics. 80% of your donation directly funds our reforestation program. 15% funds our feminine empowerment and social change work. 5% supports TreeSisters core costs to curate and deliver the above as explained here. On average, each US dollar donation funds two trees or 1 tree costs 40p as of April 15th, 2020.
Eden Reforestation: Lead and first photo Madgascar, Second photo Nepal, Third photo West Papua/Indonesia
Fourth photo Lauriane Cayet-Boisrobert
Fifth and Sixth Photos Project Greenhands India
1.Trees are in fact tree seedlings or saplings coming from a tree nursery. They can be naturally-grown wildings or propagules and have been transferred to the reforestation site. They may have been seeded or they are being assisted to naturally regenerate.
2. The process of regreening increases tree cover outside forests, on lands which were formerly forested but are today reserved for farming activity or other land uses.
3. Our reforestation partners have an idea of the expected average mortality rate because of their reforestation experience in the area. They are ready to replace the dead trees in case of relatively high mortality losses to retain the number of trees agreed upon. In Kenya for example, our reforestation partner International Tree Foundation replaces the trees that have died if mortality exceeds 10%, and to a certain extent of course.
4. Kissinger, G., M. Herold, V. De Sy. “Drivers of Deforestation and Forest Degradation: A Synthesis Report for REDD+ Policymakers.” Lexeme Consulting, Vancouver Canada, 2012. Available here.
5. Trees associated with intercrops or tree crops on farmlands, around farms as hedgerows, on schools, along roads, in orchards and in small woodlots.
6. Pioneer trees grow quickly covering areas of ground and creating the necessary conditions for later species in the forest succession to grow. They are critical to prepare the land for the successional communities.
7. More mature-forest species will grow naturally or be assisted to grow naturally, or elses, they will be planted (enrichment planting).
8. We define “reforestation” as increasing forest cover and tree cover outside forest areas.